Edgar Vandy: the brothers’ mediumship sittings and the records they kept

After Edgar Vandy drowned in 1933, his brothers sought information through several mediums. What makes the case enduring is the record-keeping: assumed names, shorthand notes, correspondence and the comparison of statements from different sittings. The published file lets readers examine a human search for answers through the documents it left behind.

AI-generated painted illustration of a symbolic 1930s notebook and radio coil; not an actual Vandy séance, document or device.
AI-generated illustration based on the reported account; not a photograph or evidence. UKPX / OpenAI, 21 November 2026. Symbolic setting, not a reconstruction.

The surviving report

Kathleen Gay’s account appeared in the Journal of the Society for Psychical Research in 1957. The SPR now provides an authorised PDF reproduction. Its introduction explains that records, unavailable to George Vandy for years during and after the war, returned to him in 1953 before he submitted them for publication.

Publication in 1957 therefore did not mark a new drowning or a fresh series of experiments. Nor does the later electronic reproduction supply a new incident year. The principal sequence belongs to 1933–1934. This entry draws on selected original passages and a later research discussion; it does not claim a full modern re-investigation of the death.

What the brothers were trying to learn

Edgar’s death occurred on 6 August 1933. The brothers wanted to explore uncertainties about its circumstances. The sittings involved different mediums and efforts to conceal the sitters’ identities. In the original report, the notes include what the sitters said as well as what the medium offered.

That last detail is important to the reader. An isolated statement can sound different when the preceding question or response is restored. A transcript allows a sequence to be examined, rather than turning a later family recollection into a line the medium supposedly said unaided. The source also distinguishes an immediate sitting record from annotations explaining a proposed match.

Several sittings, rather than one séance

The first documented sitting with Frances Campbell was held on 24 August 1933. Later sessions involved other mediums, including Gladys Osborne Leonard. One original passage identifies Edgar’s companion on the day of his death as the note-taker at that first sitting. His presence matters when assessing what information was known in the room.

The preserved material is consequently more complex than the phrase proxy case suggests. Some sessions involved a brother who knew much of Edgar’s life; others involved an intermediary. These settings raise different questions about information and should not be combined into an imaginary single controlled session.

Why researchers continued to discuss it

In her 2010 essay, Emily Williams Kelly highlighted the recurring topics across several mediums and the two brothers’ sittings. She explicitly noted that the case was not primarily a proxy case, although Drayton Thomas conducted proxy sittings. Her discussion places the episode within a programme of questions for future mediumship research.

The distinction is constructive rather than dismissive. A striking correspondence may invite further investigation, while its interpretation depends on what participants knew and how the match was documented. Living-person ESP and survival interpretations ask different questions about the same material. A report of personal details alone does not automatically choose between them.

The later phase in the original record

Gay’s conclusion describes a January 1934 sitting with Edgar’s technical assistant, intended to elicit further detail about his invention. It did not produce the hoped-for new technical information. The report also says the later sequence became repetitive and was eventually brought to an end.

Retaining that endpoint makes the original enquiry easier to understand. The record contains both the passages that attracted attention and the point at which its participants obtained little more. It should be read as a developing series, with individual sittings and their circumstances intact.

Outcome, geography and further reading

UKPX records Open (Unresolved) for the interpretation of the mediumship material. This is not a revised coroner’s verdict or an allegation about the people present at Edgar’s death. A separate historical investigation would require the relevant inquest and other contemporary records, not an inference from a later supernatural interpretation.

The case location describes the London sittings, while noting the Sussex death separately. The map uses a broad London city reference for the documented sittings, checked against a published London coordinate reference. It does not identify a particular séance room, private address or the Sussex death location. There is no visitor-access recommendation.

The illustration is an original symbolic desk scene. It does not reproduce an actual notebook, device, séance room or sitter’s likeness. The original report and Kelly’s later essay are linked so readers can follow the source trail beyond this introduction.

Sources and review

Sources checked 21 November 2026. Kathleen Gay, original 1957 report, SPR authorised PDF reproduction · Emily Williams Kelly, Some Directions for Mediumship Research,2010, especially pp 272–273 · SPR Psi Encyclopedia overview and bibliography